top of page

Liberty Safe Or, Not So Safe. Privacy Issue or Rule of Law?

Liberty Safe is a well-known American manufacturer of gun safes and security products. Founded in 1988, Liberty Safe has established a reputation for producing high-quality safes designed to protect firearms and other valuables from theft, fire, and other potential hazards.

However, they don't build safes to keep out law enforcement.

vault by
Liberty Gun Safes will now feel the backlash from consumers

Here's some fast facts about Liberty Safe:

Location: Liberty Safe is headquartered in Payson, Utah, USA. The company's manufacturing facilities are also located in Utah. They have a large manufacturing operation, which has allowed them to become one of the leading manufacturers of residential and commercial safes in the United States.

Product Range: Liberty Safe offers a wide range of safes, including home safes, gun safes, fire-resistant safes, and commercial safes. Their products are designed to provide secure storage for firearms, important documents, jewelry, and other valuables. Many of their safes are built with advanced security features, including fireproofing and various locking mechanisms.

Reputation: Liberty Safe is often recognized for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. They have been in the industry for several decades and have received numerous positive reviews from customers.

The Liberty Safe Debacle Privacy Issue or Rule of Law?

Liberty Safe provided law enforcement with the passcode to a safe belonging to a participant in the January 6 protest. Whether it is this incident or any other situation, it would raise important questions and concerns related to privacy, security, and legal matters. Such an action could potentially have significant implications for individual rights and the broader debate surrounding data access and protection.

In general, situations where a company or individual provides access to private and secure information, such as the passcode to a safe or the decryption key to encrypted data, are complex and often involve a delicate balance between individual privacy and law enforcement's need for access to evidence in criminal investigations.

Here are a few key considerations:

Legal and Ethical Implications

The decision to provide law enforcement with access to a safe's passcode would likely be subject to legal and ethical scrutiny. It would depend on the specific circumstances, applicable laws, and the rights of the individual in question. Legal authorities may need to obtain a warrant or court order to access such information, and this process would vary by jurisdiction. This is called rule of law.

User Consent

If the individual who owns the safe provided the passcode voluntarily or gave consent for it to be shared with law enforcement, this would be a factor in the decision. Consent plays a crucial role in determining the legitimacy of such actions.

Privacy Concerns

Many people value their privacy and expect their personal information and belongings to remain confidential and secure. Any breach of this trust can lead to concerns about individual privacy rights.

Transparency and Accountability

It's important for companies like Liberty Gun Safes to be transparent about their data access policies and how they handle customer information. Accountability and clear procedures for situations involving law enforcement requests are essential.

Legal Safeguards

Laws and regulations regarding data access and privacy differ by country and region. Companies must adhere to these laws while respecting the rights of their customers.

Ultimately, the balance between privacy and law enforcement's need for access to evidence is a complex and evolving issue. It often requires careful consideration of legal, ethical, and societal factors. It's essential for such situations to be handled with transparency, accountability, and adherence to applicable laws and regulations to protect the rights and interests of all parties involved.

It's Safe To Say (pun intended)

There will be implications. Right, wrong, or indifferent Liberty Safe will take a huge hit from the 2A community. Gun safe owners will be selling their safes in droves, and it the opinion of this author that Liberty Safes will take a 15% hit in coming months. If Bud Light taught us anything, it is that principled people will be heard. They will make you listen with their money.

A Case For Zero Knowledge

Zero is a likely number Liberty Safes will be seeing for a while. "Zero knowledge" usually refers to data security and encrypted products and services.

In the context of non-technical products Zero knowledge doesn't directly refer to encryption or data security but can be a concept applied to enhance user privacy, trust, and customer-centric features in various products and services.

Here's a non-technical explanation of Zero Knowledge outside cryptography and data storage:

Privacy Issue - Zero Knowledge in Non-Technical Products

Imagine you're considering buying a new product or subscribing to a service. You'd want to be assured that the company behind it respects your privacy and doesn't intrude on your personal information more than necessary. That's where the concept of "zero knowledge" can come into play, even in non-technical products:

Zero Knowledge Customer Support

When you have an issue with your product or service, you might need to contact customer support. A company practicing "zero knowledge" in this context means that their customer support team doesn't pry into your personal details unless absolutely required. They only ask for information essential to address your specific problem, ensuring your personal data is protected.

Zero Knowledge Subscription Models

In subscription-based services, a company might collect data about your usage habits. However, a "zero knowledge" approach would mean that they collect only the data necessary for providing the service, without tracking your every move or sharing your information with third parties for targeted advertising.

Zero Knowledge Loyalty Programs

Loyalty programs can collect a lot of data about your buying habits. A "zero knowledge" loyalty program would use this data to offer you relevant rewards without extensively profiling you or sharing your information with marketers.

Zero Knowledge Personalization

Many products and services offer personalization based on your preferences. A "zero knowledge" approach would mean personalizing your experience without accessing or storing excessive information about you. For example, an online retailer might suggest products without needing to know your detailed browsing history.

Zero Knowledge Feedback Collection

Companies often seek customer feedback to improve their products. In a "zero knowledge" approach, they'd collect feedback without asking for unnecessary personal information, respecting your privacy while still gathering valuable insights.

The essence of "zero knowledge" in non-technical products is to build trust and protect user privacy while delivering a valuable and personalized experience. It's about companies taking a respectful and ethical approach to handling customer data, ensuring that they only gather and use what's necessary for the product or service to function effectively, without infringing on your personal space or information.

Why Safe Manufacturers Keep a Master Safe Code

Manufacturers of safes often include a master code or override feature for several practical reasons:

Emergency Access: The master code or override key is typically intended for emergency situations when the primary access method, such as a digital keypad or combination dial, fails or is forgotten. It serves as a fail-safe mechanism to ensure that owners can still access the contents of the safe, even if they've lost the primary access method.

Customer Support and Service: Manufacturers may need a way to assist customers who encounter difficulties with their safes, including lockouts due to forgotten codes. Having a master code allows customer support representatives or locksmiths to help customers regain access to their safes without damaging the safe or its contents.

Maintenance and Repairs: Safe maintenance or repair may require temporary access to the safe's interior. The master code can be used by qualified technicians to perform necessary servicing without causing damage to the safe or compromising its security features.

Lost or Forgotten Combinations: Users sometimes forget their combinations or codes. Instead of resorting to more invasive methods like drilling or cutting the safe open, which can damage the safe and its contents, having a master code provides a less destructive way to regain access.

Security Measures: Manufacturers implement strict security protocols for the master codes to ensure that they are not easily accessible by unauthorized individuals. These codes are typically stored securely and made available only to trained personnel or authorized service providers.

It's important to note that while the existence of a master code provides a safety net for users, it also represents a potential security vulnerability if it were to fall into the wrong hands. To mitigate this risk, reputable safe manufacturers take great care to protect the master code, often using encryption and strict access controls to ensure that only authorized individuals or service providers can access it. Users should also be cautious about sharing the master code and should store it securely, separate from the safe itself, to prevent unauthorized access.

But really what then is "unauthorized access"?

liberty gun safe
A typical built gun safe. This one is by Liberty Safe

How Law Enforcement Gains Access To a Safe

Access to a person's safe by law enforcement typically involves a legal process that respects the individual's rights and privacy. Here's an overview of how law enforcement may gain access to a person's safe:

Search Warrant

To access a safe, law enforcement typically starts by obtaining a search warrant from a court. A search warrant is a legal document that authorizes the police to search a specific location, including the contents of a safe, for evidence related to a crime. To obtain a search warrant, law enforcement must demonstrate to a judge that there is probable cause to believe that evidence of a crime is present in the location to be searched.

Execution of the Warrant

Once the search warrant is issued, law enforcement officers execute it by going to the location specified in the warrant, which may include a residence or business. They must present the warrant to the person in control of the premises, explain the purpose of the search, and conduct the search in accordance with the warrant's scope.

Opening the Safe

If the search warrant specifically authorizes the search of a safe or the seizure of items from the safe, law enforcement may require the person to provide the combination or access code to open the safe. If the person refuses or is unable to provide access, law enforcement may employ locksmiths or safe experts to open the safe without damaging it. This is typically done in the presence of the person or with their representative witnessing the process.

Inventory and Seizure

Law enforcement officers are required to make an inventory of the items they seize from the safe, and they must follow proper procedures for handling and preserving evidence.

It's important to note that the process of accessing a safe is subject to strict legal guidelines and safeguards to protect an individual's Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable searches and seizures. Law enforcement must adhere to these procedures, and any evidence obtained in violation of these rights may be excluded from legal proceedings.

Furthermore, the specific laws and procedures governing search and seizure can vary by jurisdiction, so it's important for individuals to be aware of their legal rights and consult with legal counsel if they have concerns about law enforcement accessing their safe or conducting a search.

Could A Safe Be Built With Zero Knowledge?

I am not a safe cracker, locksmith or a manufacturer. But, I would be willing to bet that there is a way to create a locking mechanism that does not have a master passcode, or built with the ability to override it or reassign the code. This sounds like an opportunity for another safe company to come up with some new marketing material that will likely work.

Decentralized Identity

Decentralized identity, often referred to as "self-sovereign identity" or "SSI," is a concept in the field of digital identity management. It represents a shift away from the traditional model of centralized identity management, where organizations or authorities control and verify individuals' identities, toward a more user-centric and privacy-focused approach.

Here are the key elements of decentralized identity:

User Control: In a decentralized identity system, individuals have greater control over their personal information and digital identities. They are the primary custodians of their identity data and can decide when and how to share it.

Privacy: Decentralized identity emphasizes privacy and data minimization. Users can choose to share only the specific attributes or claims required for a particular interaction, without revealing unnecessary personal information.

Interoperability: Decentralized identity systems aim to be interoperable across various platforms and services. This means that a user's digital identity can be used across multiple applications, reducing the need for redundant identity verification.

Distributed Ledger Technology: Many decentralized identity systems leverage blockchain or other distributed ledger technologies to secure and verify identity data. These technologies provide a tamper-resistant and auditable record of identity claims and transactions.

Verifiable Credentials: Instead of relying on traditional ID cards or centralized databases, decentralized identity systems use verifiable digital credentials. These are digitally signed statements or claims made by trusted parties (e.g., government agencies, educational institutions) that can be independently verified.

User Consent: Users must explicitly consent to the sharing of their identity data. They have the ability to control who can access their information and for what purposes.

Reduced Identity Theft Risk: Decentralized identity can reduce the risk of identity theft and data breaches because sensitive personal information is not stored in a single central repository that can be compromised.

Cross-Border Use: Decentralized identity has the potential to simplify identity verification in cross-border contexts, as it can provide a standardized and portable way to prove one's identity.

Decentralized identity is still an emerging field with ongoing developments and adoption challenges. However, it holds promise for improving user privacy and control over personal data while also enhancing security and convenience in various digital interactions, such as online authentication, access control, and identity verification.

Could decentralized identity technology be used to build future safes?

The Privacy Tangent

Okay, so we are going off the rails here talking about zero knowledge and if that can apply to manufacturing or customization, talking about building a safe where there is no master passcode held by the manufacturer; and talking about decentralized identity technology.

We will digress. The point is that Liberty Safe did what they thought they had to legally do. Their legal department advised them accordingly and they did so. They were issued with a warrant, complied, and likely did nothing any other company would not have done.

The whole question now is, how can this be avoided in the future? Of course, there is the Rule of Law and it does allow for a warrant where there is clear probable cause.

The issue now becomes, what can a company do to distance themselves from any future backlash with their products and services? Provide products with zero knowledge is the answer.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page