top of page

The Guide To Understanding The Distinction Between Blackmail and Extortion


We've all seen the rise in a plethora of cybercrimes, including the nefarious acts of blackmail and extortion. These crimes are not new, but they have evolved with the internet, taking on a new form known as 'sextortion'. If you find yourself or someone you know ensnared in these types of situations, understanding the differences, implications, and how to tackle them is crucial. This post will delve deep into these topics and guide those who may be considering hiring a privacy expert.


hacker on computer doing blackmail
Your blackmailer may be the guy next door.


 

What You Will Learn - Table of Contents


 

A Primer on Blackmail & Extortion


Blackmail

Historically, the term 'blackmail' finds its origins in the border regions of Scotland and England. Farmers were forced to pay 'mail' or rent in silver coins, also known as 'white money'. When raiders demanded a tribute in return for protection and not causing harm, this payment was called 'black money', leading to the term 'blackmail'. Today, it's a crime involving threats to reveal embarrassing, disgraceful, or damaging information about a person unless a demand (often for money) is met.


Extortion

Extortion is slightly broader in its definition. It refers to the criminal act of obtaining something, especially money, through force or threats. It can be both tangible (money, property) and intangible (favor or influence).


The primary difference between blackmail and extortion lies in the nature of the threat. Blackmail involves threats of revealing damaging information, while extortion can be based on any threat, including physical harm.





Noteworthy Historical Examples

Oscar Wilde

One of the most famous cases in literary circles revolves around Oscar Wilde and the Marquess of Queensberry. In 1895, Queensberry left a card for Wilde at his club, accusing him of being a "posing somdomite" (misspelling "sodomite"). Wilde, spurred by emotion and the urgings of his young lover (Queensberry's son), decided to sue Queensberry for libel. However, Queensberry's lawyers presented evidence of Wilde's relationships with young men. Wilde dropped the lawsuit, but the tables turned. Armed with the evidence, prosecutors charged Wilde with "gross indecency." Wilde was eventually sentenced to two years of hard labor. While not a straightforward blackmail case, it bears many of the trademarks — threats, exposure, and a devastating fall from grace.


J. Edgar Hoover

As the director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Hoover amassed secret dossiers on many prominent Americans, from politicians to activists. There are numerous accounts suggesting that he used this information to keep critics at bay and maintain his powerful position for almost five decades. This brand of institutional blackmail left a lasting impact on American politics and civil liberties.


The Profumo Affair

In the early 1960s, a scandal shook the British establishment involving John Profumo, the Secretary of State for War, and a 19-year-old showgirl named Christine Keeler. Profumo had an affair with Keeler, not knowing she was also involved with a Soviet naval attaché. The situation was ripe for potential blackmail, with national security implications given the Cold War backdrop. While no direct evidence of blackmail was found, the scandal led to Profumo's resignation and significantly damaged the Conservative government's reputation.


The Evolution in Modern Times

Historically, blackmail was primarily conducted in person or through written notes, relying heavily on physical evidence. The modern digital age, however, has revolutionized the craft of blackmail. Today, perpetrators can hide behind the veil of online anonymity, dispatching threats via email, messaging apps, or even social media platforms. This digital evolution has made it easier for would-be blackmailers to cast a wider net, targeting individuals across continents.

However, the essence remains consistent through ages and mediums: the exploitation of private information or secrets for personal gain.

In summary, understanding the history and notable examples of blackmail underscores its prevalence and persistence in human societies. While the methods and nuances might change with time, the fundamentals — leveraging another's vulnerability for gain — remain unerringly consistent.

Psychological Underpinnings


Blackmail often trades on personal secrets. The very nature of blackmail means the victim has something they'd rather keep hidden. This could be an extramarital affair, a hidden past, or any activity that, if revealed, would bring shame, embarrassment, or detriment to their personal, professional, or social standing. The blackmailer wields power by preying on the victim's fear of exposure.


Extortion uses a slightly different psychological mechanism. While blackmail plays on shame and reputation, extortion often leverages fear in a more direct manner. This can involve threats of physical harm to oneself, loved ones, or property. The victim's compliance is often driven by the primary instinct of self-preservation or protection of loved ones.


Techniques Employed by Perpetrators

Understanding the techniques and methodologies used by blackmailers is not merely a dark voyage into the criminal mind but an essential step for potential victims to armor themselves against such threats. From leveraging personal secrets to exploiting someone's digital naivety, the techniques are as varied as they are insidious. Let's explore these tactics, both old and new.


Emotional Manipulation

Many blackmail cases, especially those not immediately driven by financial motives, begin with emotional manipulation. The blackmailer typically:

  • Builds trust: They might pretend to be a confidant, friend, or lover. By forging this bond, they ensure that the victim shares secrets or compromising information willingly.

  • Creates an emotional dependency: The perpetrator might position themselves as an essential pillar in the victim’s life, making it difficult for the victim to see the situation objectively or seek help.

Gathering of Information

In today's data-driven world, information is power. A blackmailer's strategies might include:

  • Direct observation: Keeping an eye on a target's habits, friendships, and routines can provide ample material.

  • Digital espionage: Using malware, keyloggers, or phishing scams, perpetrators can gain unauthorized access to a victim's personal files, photos, emails, or messages.

  • Social media stalking: Many users inadvertently share a plethora of personal details on social media platforms, making it a goldmine for potential blackmailers.

Creation of Compromising Material

Sometimes, the blackmailer might not wait for compromising material to fall into their lap. Instead, they manufacture it. Methods include:

  • Staged incidents: The perpetrator sets up scenarios where the victim is caught in a compromising situation, often without their knowledge or under deceit.

  • Deepfakes and digital editing: With advancements in technology, creating authentic-looking but entirely fake images or videos is more accessible than ever.

Isolation of the Victim

To ensure compliance and decrease the likelihood of external interventions, blackmailers often:

  • Drive wedges: They might spread rumors or use the shared secrets to create misunderstandings between the victim and their support system.

  • Engender shame: By making the victim feel solely responsible or deeply ashamed, the blackmailer can keep them silent, ensuring they don’t seek help.

Incremental Demand Strategy

Many blackmailers avoid making huge demands immediately. Instead:

  • Start small: Initial demands may be minor, ensuring the victim complies without thinking about the long-term implications.

  • Gradual escalation: As the victim gets accustomed to meeting demands, they grow in frequency and magnitude. This desensitizes the victim, making them more compliant over time.

Veiled and Direct Threats

A blackmailer's arsenal would be incomplete without threats, which can range from subtle to overt:

  • Hinting at consequences: Before laying out explicit threats, a perpetrator might hint at the adverse outcomes of non-compliance.

  • Direct threats: These are unmistakable in their intent, such as sharing compromising material, causing physical harm, or damaging reputations.

Using Third-party Platforms

Blackmailers often use platforms that allow anonymity or leave minimal digital footprints:

  • Anonymous email services: Services that don’t require real personal information or those that focus on privacy can be misused to send threats.

  • Cryptocurrency for payments: The decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies makes tracing transactions difficult, which can be attractive for blackmailers demanding money.

Fake Claims and Bluffs

Not all threats made by blackmailers are based on real information or capabilities:

  • Bluffing: A perpetrator might claim to have compromising information without possessing anything substantive, hoping the sheer threat is enough to scare the victim into compliance.

  • Misrepresentation: A harmless piece of information or image might be presented as damaging, banking on the victim’s panic rather than actual content.

Continuous Monitoring

To ensure ongoing control over the victim, many blackmailers employ:

  • Spyware: Software covertly installed on the victim’s device can give the blackmailer access to real-time information.

  • Feedback loops: They might have the victim perform tasks or acts that provide continuous compromising material, keeping the cycle ongoing.

The tactics employed by blackmailers are multifaceted and continuously evolving, especially in the digital age. Awareness of these strategies is the first line of defense. Individuals must be cautious about their digital footprints, guard their personal information, and always prioritize their safety and well-being over the demands of a malicious actor.



Socio-Economic Impact of Blackmail & Extortion

Beyond the personal trauma and harm caused to victims, blackmail and extortion have broader societal and economic implications:

  1. Economic Drain: Especially in cases of large-scale extortion rackets, there can be significant financial losses. When businesses are targeted, this can lead to job losses, reduced economic activity, and even bankruptcy.

  2. Societal Fear: News of extortion, especially if violent, can lead to widespread fear in communities, impacting daily life and routines.

  3. Mistrust in Digital Platforms: With the rise of online blackmail and sextortion, there's an increasing mistrust in digital platforms. This can stymie digital innovation, as users become wary of sharing personal information online.

  4. Legal and Law Enforcement Challenges: The often borderless nature of these crimes, especially when carried out online, presents significant challenges for law enforcement agencies. Jurisdictional issues, differing legal frameworks, and the sheer anonymity of the internet can hamper effective intervention.

Prevention and Protection

While it's difficult to predict or prevent every potential threat, there are measures individuals and businesses can adopt to minimize risk:

  1. Educate & Stay Informed: Understand the common tactics used by perpetrators. Recognizing a potential threat early on can prevent it from escalating.

  2. Limit Online Exposure: Be cautious about the personal information you share online. Regularly check your privacy settings on social media platforms.

  3. Secure Communication: Use encrypted communication channels, especially when sharing sensitive information.

  4. Maintain Backups: Regularly backup essential data. In some extortion schemes, perpetrators might threaten or execute data destruction.

  5. Be Skeptical: If something seems too good to be true online, it probably is. Avoid falling into traps by maintaining a healthy level of skepticism.

In summary, as we've delved deeper into the realms of blackmail and extortion, it becomes evident that while the mediums and methods might have evolved, the basic principles of these crimes remain rooted in leveraging human fears and vulnerabilities. Being informed, cautious, and proactive in our personal and digital lives is our best defense.



Tiner app blackmail expert Steven Grey
Dating apps are rife with bad people looking to blackmail you

The Rise and Ramifications of Sextortion: A Modern Menace

The rapid proliferation of the internet and the integral role it plays in modern communication has, unfortunately, brought with it a new wave of cybercrimes. Among the most insidious of these is sextortion. With intimate conversations and moments increasingly being captured digitally, the potential for misuse has grown exponentially, leading to a grim reality where personal boundaries are often violated with impunity.


What is Sextortion?

While we've touched upon the basic definition of sextortion as the act of demanding something, typically money, in exchange for not revealing compromising photos or videos, it's crucial to understand its depth. Sextortion blurs the lines between cyberbullying, revenge porn, and traditional extortion. It can be initiated by strangers met online, former romantic partners, or even known acquaintances looking to exert power and control.


How Does Sextortion Begin?

  1. Relationship Pretense: One common method perpetrators use is to form a seemingly genuine online relationship with their targets. Once trust is established, they coax or trick victims into sharing intimate photos or videos. Once they have the compromising material, the actual intent is revealed.

  2. Hacking and Unauthorized Access: Some sextortion cases arise from hackers gaining unauthorized access to a person's device, retrieving private photos or conversations, and then using them as leverage.

  3. Hidden Cameras: In more sinister cases, perpetrators use hidden cameras in changing rooms, rental properties, or even in the homes of acquaintances to capture compromising footage.

  4. Impersonation and Catfishing: By pretending to be someone else, often a romantic interest, scammers can deceive individuals into sharing intimate material.

The Psychological Impact on Victims

The aftermath of sextortion can be devastating. Beyond the immediate threat and fear, victims often experience:

  1. Shame and Embarrassment: Given the intimate nature of the material being used against them, many victims feel profound shame, even if they've been deceived or betrayed.

  2. Isolation: Due to the stigma associated, victims might retreat from friends and family, feeling they have nowhere to turn.

  3. Depression and Anxiety: The persistent fear of exposure can lead to chronic anxiety. In some cases, this trauma can lead to depression or even suicidal thoughts.

  4. Financial Strain: If the victim decides to pay the perpetrator (though not recommended), it can put them under immense financial stress.

The Broader Social Implications

Sextortion doesn't just affect its immediate victims; it reverberates through society in various ways:

  1. Mistrust in Online Platforms: As sextortion cases make headlines, people become increasingly wary of online interactions. This skepticism can hinder genuine relationships and deter people from using online platforms, stunting digital social growth.

  2. Legal Gray Areas: While many countries are updating their laws to tackle sextortion, the digital nature of the crime creates jurisdictional challenges. This often results in perpetrators escaping due to legislative loopholes or international boundaries.

  3. Normalization of Cyberbullying: The more pervasive sextortion becomes, the more desensitized society might become to online threats and cyberbullying, making the internet a hostile space for many.

Combating Sextortion: Protective Measures

While the threat of sextortion is real and growing, there are proactive steps individuals can take:

  1. Be Cautious: Before sharing any intimate material, think about the potential long-term implications. Remember that once something is digital, it's nearly impossible to erase it completely.

  2. Use Encrypted Platforms: If you're sharing sensitive material or having private conversations, use encrypted platforms that offer end-to-end encryption.

  3. Regularly Update Security: Ensure your devices are updated, and use strong, unique passwords. Regularly review app permissions, ensuring no unauthorized apps have access to your camera or storage.

  4. Educate and Communicate: Talk to younger members in the family about the risks and implications of sharing intimate content. Open dialogue can be a preventative tool.

What to Do If Targeted?

  1. Do Not Pay or Negotiate: While it might seem tempting to make the problem go away, paying rarely guarantees safety. It can embolden the perpetrator, making them more demanding.

  2. Preserve All Communication: Before blocking the perpetrator, ensure you've saved all communications, as these can be used as evidence.

  3. Report to Privacy Expert: Contact a privacy expert. Law enforcement is not adequately trained, nor are lawyers - who want nothing more than to suck your blood dry.


In conclusion, sextortion epitomizes the dark side of the digital revolution, turning tools of connection into weapons of coercion. As with all threats, awareness, education, and proactive measures are the best defense. Society at large must recognize sextortion for the menace it is and work collaboratively, both at the grassroots and legislative levels, to combat it.


How Do Blackmail and Extortion Happen?

  1. Traditional Methods: Blackmail and extortion have long been practiced via face-to-face threats, letters, or phone calls.

  2. Digital Evolution: With technology, criminals often use emails, social media, messaging apps, or any form of digital communication to carry out their threats.

  3. Online Scams: The blackmailer may pose as a potential romantic interest, starting a relationship with the target, only to later threaten them with exposure unless they pay or meet other demands.

  4. Hacking and Data Breaches: Sometimes, personal data is accessed via breaches or hacks, giving the criminals ammunition for blackmail.

  5. Malware and Spyware: These can be used to access personal data, photos, or videos from a person's device, which can then be used for extortion.

Tackling Online Blackmail or Sextortion

If you find yourself a victim of online blackmail or sextortion:

  1. Do Not Pay: Giving in to demands might provide a short-term solution, but it doesn't guarantee your safety or that the blackmailer won't come back for more.

  2. Document Everything: Save all communications, including messages, emails, or any other form of contact. This can be essential for legal proceedings.

  3. Avoid Communication: As tempting as it might be to reason with the blackmailer, it's better to cease all communication.

  4. Update Security: Ensure your online accounts have strong, unique passwords. Enable two-factor authentication where possible. This can help protect against future threats.

  5. Law Enforcement: Although it seems like the right thing to do, and we won't pursuade you otherwise – it is useless. Law enforcement will not take the average blackmail or sextortion case under their wing. They do not know how to manage these matters.

  6. Hire a Professional: Rather than police, and lawyers, you will need to hire an expert in blackmail and sextortion.



Who Are the Usual Targets?

While anyone can be a victim, the following groups are often targeted:


Celebrities & Public Figures

Their public status makes them prime targets, with perpetrators hoping to gain money or fame. Our public figure blackmail client percentage is less than 5% of our blackmail mitigation work.


Business Executives

High net-worth individuals or those with influential positions are often threatened with personal or professional damage. Executives account for approximately 26% of our blackmail clientele.


Average Individuals

With the rise of online dating and social media, everyday people can also become targets, especially if they share personal or intimate details online. Average people make up the majority of our clients for blackmail and sextortion matters with 69% being the normal person next door with an average age of 52 years old.


Seeking the Help of a Privacy Expert

In dire circumstances, when the threat seems unmanageable, seeking a privacy expert can be a game-changer. Here's why:

  1. Expert Guidance: They can provide guidance on how to handle the situation, based on their experience with similar cases.

  2. Digital Footprint Review: They can assess your online presence and advise on any potential vulnerabilities or ways to reduce future risks.

  3. Legal Liaison: A privacy expert can liaise with law enforcement, if need be, ensuring all necessary information is shared and that you're protected legally.

  4. Emotional Support: While they're not therapists, they understand the trauma victims go through and can provide an empathetic ear and advice on seeking further emotional support.

Statistics From Our Blackmail Cases From 2020 to 2023

% of Cases

Average Age Female/Male

Average Financial Loss

Average Time Before Loss

Sextortion

​72%

​52/46

​$3,900

​5 Weeks

Blackmail

​28%

​60/52

​$1740

​6 Weeks

Met on Online Dating App

​59%

​43/57

​$912

​5 Weeks

Met on Social Media

​41%

​61/59

$2,275

3 Weeks


How to Contact a Privacy Expert

If you are looking for a privacy expert to help you during or after a blackmail event, you can reach out to us here on this site. With an expert consultation, you will have the correct information to deal with the matter carefully and effectively.


In Conclusion

While the digital age has brought many conveniences, it has also given rise to complex challenges like blackmail, extortion, and sextortion. Being informed is the first line of defense. Whether you're dealing with such a situation or are cautious about potential risks, understanding the distinctions and knowing when and how to seek expert help can make all the difference. Remember, you're never alone in this – there are professionals who will help you now.



FAQs on Blackmail, Extortion, and Sextortion

Blackmail

Q1: What is blackmail?

A1: Blackmail is the act of threatening to reveal embarrassing, disgraceful, or damaging information about a person unless certain demands, often monetary, are met.


Q2: Is there a difference between blackmail and extortion?

A2: While both involve coercing someone into meeting demands under threat, the primary distinction lies in the nature of the threat. Blackmail typically uses the threat of revealing sensitive or damaging information, while extortion might involve threats of physical harm, property damage, or other broader forms of duress.


Q3: Is blackmail always about money?

A3: No, while many blackmail cases involve demands for money, blackmailers can also demand favors, actions, or anything else of value.


Extortion

Q4: How is extortion typically carried out?

A4: Extortion can be executed in many ways, from physical threats in person to online demands. It might involve threats of physical violence, destruction of property, or any other actions that would harm the victim.


Q5: What should one do if they are being extorted?

A5: Do not give in to the demands. Preserve all evidence, document all interactions, and share it with a privacy expert.


Sextortion

Q6: What is sextortion?

A6: Sextortion is a form of blackmail where someone threatens to reveal intimate images, videos, or details about an individual unless they comply with their demands, which could be monetary, additional compromising materials, or other requests.


Q7: How do perpetrators typically acquire compromising material for sextortion?

A7: There are various methods, including hacking into a victim's devices, deceiving them into sharing explicit content (e.g., in online relationships), recording intimate encounters without consent, or exploiting images shared willingly in a trusting relationship.


Q8: How can one protect themselves from becoming a victim of sextortion?

A8: Be cautious when sharing personal or intimate details online, even in seemingly private or trustworthy situations. Regularly update device security, use strong passwords, and avoid clicking on suspicious links. Educate oneself about common online scams and threats.


Q9: What should someone do if they are a victim of sextortion? A9: Do not comply with the demands. Preserve all evidence of communication, block the perpetrator, report the situation to local law enforcement, and seek legal guidance. Many countries are now treating sextortion as a serious crime, and law enforcement can often provide guidance or support.


Q10: Are there specific groups or demographics more vulnerable to sextortion?

A10: While anyone can be a victim, younger individuals, particularly teenagers who are more active online and might not be fully aware of the risks, are often targeted. People who engage in online dating or have shared intimate content digitally are also at higher risk.


Q11: Are blackmail, extortion, and sextortion crimes in most jurisdictions?

A11: Yes, in most jurisdictions, all three are considered crimes, though the specifics of the law and the penalties can vary. .

Comments


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page